Ranking: Every Member of The Lord of the Rings Fellowship


The legacy of the Lord of the Rings will be renowned for the impact it had on the landscape of fantasy fiction. Part of the reason this epic is such a classic is down to the cast of characters making up the fellowship of the ring. These nine companions face the insurmountable task of leading the one ring to the heart of Mount Doom. Following the tragic loss of one of their companions, the fellowship find themselves scattered across the lands of Middle-Earth. Based on their contribution to the events of the movies, this is how one writer would rank the members of the Fellowship of the Ring.


Gimli GIF - Find & Share on GIPHY

Gimli proved himself to be a loyal ally and formidable warrior. Representing the dwarves, his role in the fellowship was that of a seasoned warrior. However, his stubbornness often landed them in some trouble, and let’s not forget that it was he who suggested they venture through Moria, a path with deadly consequences for the fellowship. Despite this, Gimli did provide some much-needed moments of levity and his friendship with Legolas was one of the most entertaining dynamics throughout the franchise.


Lord Of The Rings GIF - Find & Share on GIPHY

Representing his elven kin, Legolas, like Gimli provided some manpower to the fellowship. Legolas is also a seasoned warrior, and his grace in battle is a valuable asset to the men of Rohan and Gondor. His elven senses were also valuable in tracking the enemy allowing their allies to prepare for the battle ahead. Carrying the strength of one another in their darkest hour, the friendship between Legolas, Gimli, and Aragorn inspired loyalty and hope throughout Middle-Earth.


Boromir GIFs | Tenor

Considering his fate, you may wonder why Boromir ranks above Legolas and Gimli. His sacrifice had a profound effect on the entire fellowship, but for Pippin and Merry, this moment reminded them of the mortality of men. His sacrifice undoubtedly influenced the choices made by the hobbits later in the franchise, as the passing of their friend made them understand the urgency of their quest. The extended edition of the trilogy also gave us further insight into the man living with the looming threat of Mordor on his very doorstep. These scenes gave us a better understanding of how Boromir became susceptible to the wills of the ring, reminding us of its manipulative power. Trying to take the ring from Frodo was not his finest hour, but he paid the price with his life. Boromir was noble at heart, but his moment of weakness proved costly to the fellowship.


Pippin GIF - Find & Share on GIPHY

Some will argue against Pippin’s position on the list, but while his dimwitted actions often led to peril and conflict, his maturity led to a series of small and profound gestures of loyalty and strength. His defining moments came in the Return of the King as he finds himself at the heart of the war in Gondor. Understanding the gravity of their position, Pippin made the perilous climb to light the beacons, carrying a message to their allies in alerting Rohan, calling them into action. We cannot forget that he also saved Faramir from Denethor’s madness. Pippin may have been a nuisance at the start of this quest, but his maturity highlights his noble heart. 


Merry The Lord of the Rings work The Return of The King theoden ...

Wiser than Pippin, Merry proved early on that he could be resourceful and reliable, aiding Frodo on his journey to Bree. Upon joining the fellowship, Merry understood the gravity of their quest and kept Pippin in line following his foolish actions. His place may not be in war, but when the need arose, Merry stood strong alongside Eowyn and the men of Rohan. He also deserves credit for taking down the Witch-King of Angmar, the strongest of the Nazgul. Time and again hobbits prove that simple acts of courage can carry you throughout the darkest times, demonstrating their heroic qualities with their loyalty and heart.


Black Widow Thor GIF - Find & Share on GIPHY

Gandalf was the mentor providing insightful words of wisdom at our hero’s time of need. Many will make a case for Gandalf to be higher in the ranking, but the fact of the matter is Gandalf was never meant to be the hero of the story. His role on the journey was that of a guide, spurring our heroes on this perilous path. Gandalf is the voice of reason, the negotiator between the men of Middle-Earth, and an additional source of strength when facing the armies of Mordor. Yes, Gandalf is a crucial member of the fellowship, but this was never his tale.


lord of the rings frodo gif | WiffleGif

Frodo might not be your favourite character, but he did what no man could do before him, walked straight into the heart of Mount Doom and destroyed the one ring that, for so long, corrupted the hearts of men. It was Frodo, a simple hobbit, that bore the weight of the ring, and carried it through mines, marshes, and enemy lines. He kept true to his heart all the while resisting that same darkness that drove its previous bearers to madness. Never underestimate the sheer will it took for Frodo to carry the ring for as long as he did.


Return Of The King GIF - Find & Share on GIPHY

Aragorn undergoes quite the transformation on this journey. Introduced as Strider, his heroic journey sets him on the path to become the leader he was destined to be. Aragon always displayed a natural leadership, inspiring loyalty from elves, dwarves, and men alike. His skills in battle, his valour, wisdom, and compassion make him a worthy king. This franchise is as much about Aragorn’s journey as it is about the ring-bearer, with the fractured alliances among men allowing the darkness of Mordor to manipulate men of all rank. Without Aragorn, that fragile alliance would crumble. It is his leadership quality that ignites that spark of hope in a conflict that vastly outnumbers them.


Samwise Gamgee GIFs - Get the best GIF on GIPHY

Without Sam, Frodo would never have made it to Mount Doom. The choice to join the company on this perilous journey was not driven by duty, but of friendship. These hobbits willingly chose to become an active player in the fate of the world of men. Sam is as loyal as it gets, and even in their darkest moments, never leaves Frodo’s side. In the Two Towers, it was his moving speech that reminds Frodo of the strength in holding onto the good in the world. Sam never forgets his roots, knowing that should they fail, even the Shire will fall into the darkness. It’s Sam that warns Frodo of Gollums villainy and Sam who rescues Frodo from the Tower of Cirith Ungol. He is the silent hero that carries Frodo, literally and metaphorically, throughout the franchise. His quiet strength is a firm reminder of the courage found in the most unconventional heroes.

How would you rank the fellowship?
Which is your favourite film in the franchise?


13 thoughts on “Ranking: Every Member of The Lord of the Rings Fellowship

    1. Sam and Aragorn were the easiest ones on the list, but the rest of them were hard to place. It’s funny cause in regards to the novels I feel like the ranking would also be completely different.

      Liked by 1 person

  1. I agree with most of this for the movies. I probably would have put Gimli higher than Legolas and also Merry, Pippin, and Boromir higher than Aragorn. I do not think Peter Jackson got Gimli’s character very close to how Tolkien made it. He also did not, in my opinion, get Frodo, Pippin, and to some degree, Merry, too close to the book. Still, I think I agree with this for the movies.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. If I ranked them based on the books, the list would be completely different. Gimli definitely didn’t get the full treatment in the movies. I think ignoring the status of the hobbits within the lands of the Shire definitely hindered their character development in the films as well.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Very interesting ranking, Lois! To go with how much of an impact they had definitely put things differently, especially when we’re so used to a “popularity contest”. I really look forward to finally reading the trilogy now that I’ve completed and adored The Hobbit and then rewatch the movie trilogy! So much excitement in me for all this! 😀

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I completely agree with your ranking! 😀 Though I would put Legolas higher, due to the fact that child me had the biggest crush on him (plus I was obsessed with the elves). 😂

    Liked by 2 people

  4. I think Legolas and Pippin would be high on my list for the members of the Fellowship. For non-fellowship members Tauriel and Eowyn would be on the top.
    My favorite book/movie of the LOTR series was The Two Towers, though it is sad in some places I really liked it for some reason.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Funny you should mention non fellowship members because I have a ranking of them saved in my drafts. The Two Towers was my favourite in both the book and the film as well. I though the expanstion of the quest to the lands of Rohan and Gondor elevated the sense of urgency.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s